Probate in Montana
When a person dies, with or without a will, Montana laws provide a legal process to determine his or her real and personal property and for determining the market value of the assets and their distribution to appropriate parties.
One procedure, termed probate, takes place in the district court of the county where the deceased person had residence. Probate is not required for any property the decedent held in trust, or any property held in joint tenancy with right of survivorship with another person. If the deceased had real property located in another state, an “ancillary administration” proceeding in that state may be necessary.
The Montana Legislature passed the Uniform Probate Code (UPC) that provides rules to simplify probate in a district court. Probate in Montana is not nearly as burdensome or expensive as it is in other states that have not adopted the UPC. In some states, probate can be quite costly, because an attorney and personal representative must appear before the court for approval of almost every action involved in settling an estate. In Montana, formal approval by the court is not required for any action already authorized in the UPC.
This article was adapted from the Montana State university Extension Office MontGuide, "Probate in Montana," and is designed to explain some aspects of probate. It is not intended to serve as a complete guide for probate; all details could not possibly be included. Statements apply to general situations, and solutions to specific problems relating to probate often depend upon the facts of each case.
What is a Personal Representative?
Probate is the administrative process of settling an estate whether the decedent died with or without a will. If appointed, the personal representative named in your will has the responsibility of settling your estate according to the terms and provisions of it and Montana law. The personal representative may be a family member, a friend, an attorney, a corporate entity such as a bank or trust company, or a combination of these.
If you die without a will, the Montana UPC lists the order in which eligible persons may apply for appointment as a personal representative. That order is: the surviving spouse named in a will, the custodial parent of a minor decedent, other devisees (persons named in a will) of the decedent, the surviving spouse of the decedent, and other heirs (persons to receive property under intestate statutes if the decedent died without a will) of the decedent. (Further information is provided in the MontGuide, What is a Personal Representative?.)
Probate proceedings have the following major functions: to determine the validity of and interpret wills; to discover, collect, manage and protect estate assets until final distribution; to settle claims of creditors; to settle federal and state obligations, if due; to distribute the decedent’s property to his or her heirs according to Montana’s law of intestacy (dying without a will) and devisees (those named in the will); and to provide a method of securing the legal transfer of real estate or personal property ownership (cars, stocks, bonds, and so on).
Although probate may seem lengthy and detailed, it is provided by Montana law to assure that the property of the deceased is accounted for, and that all debts and taxes are paid. Someone must carry out the business of the estate and see that the property is distributed to the designated parties.
An appointment of a personal representative is not necessary if all property held by the decedent is nonprobate property. Examples of nonprobate property include: property held in joint tenancy with right of survivorship; property held in trust; life insurance payable to a named beneficiary; payable-on-death (POD) deposits at financial institutions; assets in a pension plan to named beneficiary; individual retirement accounts to designated beneficiary; and transfers-on-death (TOD) registrations on securities and securities accounts. (Further information is provided in the MontGuide, Nonprobate Transfers).
However, there are reporting requirements for these types of property for determination of Montana and federal income taxes and perhaps federal estate taxes.
Types of Estate Administration
Under Montana law, probate may be administered: as an informal proceeding; as a formal procedure; by supervised administration; by collection of personal property by affidavit; or as a small estate summary administrative procedure. An estate may be opened formally and closed informally, opened informally and closed formally, or any combination.
An application for informal probate or informal appointment of a personal representative can be directed to the clerk of a district court no sooner than 120 hours after the decedent’s death. If the clerk determines that all requirements of law have been met, he or she files the will and appoints the personal representative who can then proceed to settle the estate.
Formal probate may be necessary when no will exists, when the validity of a will may be questioned, or when parties disagree about the appointment of a personal representative or distribution of assets. With formal probate, proceedings are held before a district court judge after notice of the hearing is given to interested persons. These include heirs, devisees and any other persons or businesses having a property right in or claim against the estate.
Those who contest a will have the burden of establishing that the person who wrote it lacked testamentary intent or capacity, or was under undue influence or duress. Other circumstances for contesting a will involve fraud, mistakes or the revocation of prior wills.
In informal, formal and supervised probate procedures, creditors must be given four months to submit claims for debts after the first publication of the notice in a local newspaper. The personal representative may choose to close the estate on a formal basis six months after his or her appointment if the creditor’s claim period has expired. The personal representative must have given proper notice to interested persons, filed a final account, and determined heirs and distributed property either under the provisions of the will or the laws of intestacy.
This proceeding secures administration and settlement of a decedent’s estate under the continuing authority of the court. Supervised administration can occur in a formal or informal probate and extends until entry of an order approving distribution of the estate, and discharging the personal representative, or other order terminating the proceeding.
Collection of Personal Property by Affidavit
This procedure may be initiated 30 days after a person dies, if the value of the entire estate (less liens and encumbrances) does not exceed $50,000. Any devisee or heir may collect the personal property as well as money owed to the decedent by presenting an affidavit to individuals or institutions holding the decedent’s real or personal property.
Small Estate Summary Administration
If it appears from an inventory and appraisal that the value of the entire estate (less liens and encumbrances) does not exceed the homestead allowance of $20,000, exempt property of $10,000, family allowance of $18,000, cost and expenses of administration, reasonable funeral expenses and reasonable and necessary medical and hospital expenses of the last illness of the decedent – then a small-estate summary administrative procedure can be used. The personal representative, without giving notice to creditors, may immediately distribute the estate to the persons entitled and file a closing statement. The small estate administrative procedure can begin five days after the death of the decedent, and as soon as the personal representative determines that the value of the estate does not exceed the outstanding debt.
How Long Does Probate Take?
Because the situation in every estate varies, the schedule for each may be different. If the personal representative hires an attorney to assist with the probate, he/she should ask the attorney to provide an estimated time when the probate will be completed. In some situations, probate can be finished within six months. When the formal procedure is followed, the typical time required to complete probate is about ten months.
In other cases, where the estate includes assets that are difficult to value and where it faces federal estate taxation, the estate may not be closed until the audit of a federal estate tax return is complete. The Internal Revenue Service has three years after the filing of the return to complete an audit.
If a personal representative chooses to close an estate on an informal basis, other than for summary administrative procedure estates, he or she would file with a court a verified statement showing that he or she has complied with the Montana laws in completing the probate no earlier than six months after the date of original appointment as personal representative. If no proceedings involving the personal representative are pending one year after filing the closing statement, the appointment of the personal representative terminates.
If an estate is not closed within two years from the date the personal representative is appointed, a Supreme Court administrator will notify a district court judge. That judge will then order the personal representative and attorney to appear before the court to disclose reasons why the estate has not been closed. If there is not just cause, the judge may order the estate be closed within 30 days and declare that the attorney and personal representative receive no compensation.
What are the Responsibilities of the Personal Representative?
The personal representative has a duty to settle and distribute the estate of the decedent according to the terms of any probated will or the Montana laws of intestacy. The acknowledgement of fiduciary relationship and obligations form for a personal representative is available online on the MSU Extension Office website. A more detailed description is included in the MontGuide, Personal Representative Responsibilities, but the following responsibilities are typical:
- The personal representative notifies heirs and devisees of his or her appointment within 30 days.
- Upon his or her appointment, the personal representative publishes a notice announcing his or her appointment and address, once a week for three consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the county. The personal representative notifies creditors of the estate to present claims within four months after the first publication of the notice.
- The personal representative pays all bills and federal estate taxes (if due) from the assets of the estate and distributes the remaining assets. All expenditures must be accounted for.
- The personal representative may close the estate on an informal basis by filing with the court a verified statement stating that he or she has complied with the provision of the probate code. The estate may be closed on a formal basis after proper notice to interested persons about the times for a hearing on the final accounting, and the formal hearing before a district court judge.
What is the Cost of Probate?
There is no standard answer to this question. The cost depends on the size and complexity of the estate. In 2019, the initial filing fee to begin probate is the same in every district court – $70, which includes the fee for filing a will. The cost for copying papers in the clerk’s files is $1 per page for the first 10 pages of each file, and 50 cents for each additional page. Other costs may include publication costs, appraisals, advertising expenses for sales (if any are made), sale expenses for any auctions or property sales, and insurance premiums.
If a personal representative hires an attorney to handle legal aspects of the settlement of the estate, the attorney's compensation must be reasonable. The 2019 Legislature changed attorney's fees from a percentage of the value of the estate to a reasonable charge.
The Montana Supreme Court has established a sevenpart test applicable to all civil matters by which the reasonableness of an attorney’s fee is determined. For example, the court evaluates the requirements of the case, such as technical skills, the time required and the complexity of the issues. Consider hiring an attorney who specializes in probate.
Protections for Surviving Relatives
The UPC exempts certain property and allowances that the surviving spouse and minor children are entitled to in preference over unsecured creditors of the estate and persons to whom the estate may be devised by will. Basic family protections are: the surviving spouse’s right to an elective share, the homestead right, exempt property, and a family allowance. Any of the surviving spouse’s rights may be waived, wholly or partially, before or after marriage, by a written contract, agreement or waiver signed after fair disclosure.
Surviving Spouse’s Right to an Elective Share
This statute is effective for the surviving spouse of a decedent domiciled in Montana. He or she has the right to take an elective-share amount that is a percentage of the combined augmented estates of the decedent and the surviving spouse. The elective share increases in percentage from three to 50 percent, based on the length of the marriage (See Table 1 below).
To protect spouses in small estates, there is a minimum elective share amount of up to $50,000.
The right of election of a surviving spouse, and the rights of the surviving spouse to homestead allowance, exempt property and family allowance (or any of them), may be waived, wholly or partially, before or after marriage, by a written contract, agreement or waiver signed by the surviving spouse. A surviving spouse’s waiver is not enforceable if the surviving spouse proves that:
- The waiver was not executed voluntarily.
- The waiver was unconscionable when it was executed and, before execution of the waiver, the surviving spouse:
- was not provided a fair and reasonable disclosure of the property or financial obligations of the decedent,
- did not voluntarily and expressly waive, in writing, any right to disclosure of the property or financial obligation of the decedent beyond the disclosure provided, and
- did not have, or reasonably could not have had, an adequate knowledge of the property or financial obligation of the decedent.
The spouse’s elective share is in addition to other benefits provided under the Uniform Probate Code, including the homestead allowance of $20,000, personal property allowance of $10,000, and family allowance – a maximum of $18,000.
Surviving spouse's elective-share percentage
|If the decedent and the spouse were married to one another||If the decedent and the spouse were married to one another||The elective-share parcentage is:|
|At Least||Less Than||Percentage of augmented estate|
|2 years||3 years||6%|
|3 years||4 years||9%|
|4 years||5 years||12%|
|5 years||6 years||15%|
|6 years||7 years||18%|
|7 years||8 years||21%|
|8 years||9 years||24%|
|9 years||10 years||27%|
|10 years||11 years||30%|
|11 years||12 years||34%|
|12 years||13 years||38%|
|13 years||14 years||42%|
|14 years||15 years||46%|
|15 years or more||15 years or more||50%|
The Montana Uniform Probate Code provides an extensive definition of the augmented estate and elective share. The definition is not provided here because of its substantial length; a copy can be obtained from an attorney or from the Montana Code Annotated at a local library.
In general, the augmented estate includes assets owned by the decedent at the time of death, as well as assets over which the decedent exercised control or enjoyment, and transfers made without consideration within two years prior to death. This provision is designed to make it difficult for a decedent to intentionally disinherit a surviving spouse by giving all of his or her property away or placing it in a revocable living trust shortly before death.
A surviving spouse of a decedent who was a resident of Montana is entitled to a homestead allowance of $20,000. If there is no surviving spouse, each minor child and each dependent child of the decedent is entitled to a share of the homestead allowance amounting to $20,000 divided by the number of minor and dependent children of the decedent. The homestead allowance is exempt from and has priority over all claims against the estate, including unsecured creditors of the estate and persons to whom the estate may be devised by will.
In addition to the homestead allowance, the surviving spouse of a decedent who was a resident of Montana is entitled to value from the estate not exceeding $10,000 in excess of any security interests in household furniture, automobiles, furnishings, appliances and personal effects. If there is no surviving spouse, minor children of the decedent are entitled jointly to the same value. If there is not $10,000 worth of exempt property in the estate, the spouse or children are entitled to other assets of the estate to the extent necessary to make up the amount.
The surviving spouse and minor children whom the decedent was obligated to support, and children who were in fact being supported by him or her, are entitled to a reasonable family allowance in cash from the estate for their maintenance during the period of probate administration. The personal representative may determine the family allowance in a lump sum not exceeding $18,000, or periodic installments not exceeding $1,500 per month for one year. The district court may approve a larger sum.
If a testator fails to provide in a will for any of his or her children born or adopted after the signing of the will, the omitted child receives a share in the estate equal in value to that which he or she would have received if the testator had died intestate. The exceptions to this general rule include:
- if it appears from the will that the omission was intentional,
- if the will was executed after the testator had one or more children and left substantially all his estate to the other parent of the omitted child, or
- if the testator provided for the child by a transfer outside the will and the intent that the transfer be in lieu of a testamentary provision is shown by statements of the testator, from the amount of the transfer, or other evidence.
A provision of the UPC states that any person who fails to survive the decedent by more than 120 hours (five days) is considered to have died before the decedent for purpose of inheritance, homestead allowance, exempt property and intestacy. This statute eliminates the need for double probate on the same property in situations where several members of the same family are killed or injured, and die within a few days of each other. The 120-hour survival requirement applies to persons who die without a will, and to those who have a will without a specific survival clause.
Probate is a legal administrative process of settling an estate whether the decedent dies with or without a will. Although the procedure may seem lengthy and detailed, it assures that all property of the deceased is accounted for and that all debts and taxes are paid. Probate in Montana is not nearly as burdensome or costly as it is in states that have not adopted the UPC.
How do I find an attorney?
- The Montana Legal Services Developer in the Office on Aging, provides elder law training and resources for seniors, family members and social outreach workers. The program also develops pro bono and local legal services referrals, training materials and telephone assistance to seniors on related matters. The Legal Services Developer can be contacted by calling (800) 332-2272 (during normal business hours).
- The State Bar Lawyer Referral Service may provide you with contact information for attorneys who provide the type of assistance you are seeking, for a fee. You can contact the State Bar Lawyer Referral Service at (406) 449-6577 or montanabar.org.
- Montana Legal Services Association helps eligible Native Americans write wills for their Indian trust property, at no charge. You can apply for free legal help from Montana Legal Services Association online at http://www.mtlsa.org.
This publication is not intended to be a substitute for legal advice. Rather, it is designed to create an awareness of the need for estate planning and to help families become better acquainted with some of the devices involved. Future changes in laws cannot be predicted, and statements in the MontGuide are based solely upon the laws in force on the date of publication.
This resource was adapted from the Montana State University Extension Office MontGuide, "Probate in Montana." You can download the original resource in a PDF by using the link below.
Thank you to the Montana State University Extension Office for creating this MontGuide and allowing Montana Legal Services Association to publish it on this website.
The Business, Estates, Tax, Trusts, and Real Property Law Section, State Bar of Montana, has approved this MontGuide and recommends its reading by all Montanans.